Instructions To Reviewers


Tittle of the Article:

I. Please score the aspects list ed below on a scale of 0-5 with 5 being the highest score:                                                                                                      

  1. Originality:                        
  2. Relevance:                                                             
  3. Methodology including statistical analysis.
  4. Figures:
  5. Tables:                                                                    
  6. Bibliography:                    

II. What do you consider to be the major strengths of the manuscript?

III. What do you consider to be the major weaknesses of the manuscript?

IV. Overall judgment:

  1. The article is good and should be published as submitted.
  2. The article should be accepted after minor corrections.
  3. The article should be returned to the author for major corrections.
  4. The article is of poor quality, it should be rejected.
  5. Other comments

V Any other Comments?